Subject: Re: [harryproa] BD with tandem keel
From: Arto Hakkarainen
Date: 1/3/2010, 5:42 PM
To: harryproa@yahoogroups.com.au
Reply-to:
harryproa@yahoogroups.com.au

 

Good to hear that tandem keel works. What are the differences between your old rudder and the new rudder? Location is more aft and to leeward if I remember correctly? Other significant differences? Also you did sail with only one rudder in water with the old one if I understood correctly? If I am correct on both of these it seems that the boat is better balanced with only one rudder that is further aft and to lee which sounds like logical conclusion. Also it seems that better balance gives better speed potential which also sounds logical.
 
Arto

--- On Sun, 1/3/10, Rudolf vd Brug <rpvdb@freeler.nl> wrote:

From: Rudolf vd Brug <rpvdb@freeler.nl>
Subject: [harryproa] BD with tandem keel
To: harryproa@yahoogroups.com.au
Date: Sunday, January 3, 2010, 9:16 PM

 
Hi,
 
It has been some time since we put BD ashore next to our house.
That was December 4th, earlier that week we sailed her with the tandem keel fitted.
The keel was fitted using threaded rods in epoxy in the keel fins. We just drilled holes in the bottom of the hull,
put the rods through them and floor timbers on the inside to distribute the loads.
Plenty of sealant obviously. It took two hours including hoisting and relaunching.
As usual I forgot the camera so no photos, sorry.
 
Sailing with the keel fitted showed that we could get going with the wind at 90 deg. as with the leeboard.
It was obvious though the leeboard was more effective, we could steer close to the wind but needed more rudder angle to keep control.
Second test sail was with one of the old rudders fitted additional to the new ones.
I wanted to see if this would cause a significant difference.
We had the new rudders out of the water, so just one old rudder and the tandem keel. Sheeted in carefully and got going easily.
When at speed no noticeable rudder angle, speed up to 12.5 knots could have gone faster but we didin't seek speed.
Control with the old rudder was very precise, what I find to be missing with the new ones.
After shunting returned with the new rudders, high rudder angles 11 knots max and we could feel the power that couldn't be put to use.
 
It seems the keel works, although the leeboard was more effective. The leeboard would need more experimenting to come up with a good
way of keeping at the right angle and prevent it from kiting. I think the leeboard would have to be handled at every shunt. That is one of the reasons the owner likes the keel better.
Hopefully carefull finishing of the rudder blades will lead to smaller angles when sailing.
 
regards,
Rudolf
 

__._,_.___
.

__,_._,___