Subject: Re: [harryproa] Re: Predicting performance?
From: Mike Crawford
Date: 5/30/2010, 4:52 PM
To: harryproa@yahoogroups.com.au
Reply-to:
harryproa@yahoogroups.com.au

 

<<I had a good look at the sheeting arrangements. They sheet way back to the stern. This would not really go with the Harryproa configuration of sheeting back to the ww hull>>

  I would sheet out to a block as far aft on the leeward hull as feasible, probably near the end of the solid/framed section. 

  That would provide nicer angles for the sheets to the top wishbones (not too steep), create less stress on the wishbone joints, and make it easy to run with the sail on either side of the mast.  It would also allow the boat to be used as a tacking proa, assuming that you'd want to do such a thing, and also that the combination of hull rocker, distance between rudders, and rudder depth would allow a tack.

  The downside is that it would be possible to get caught aback.  But if you want the option of tacking, that's the point.  The worst case is that you'll have to dump the sheet if the wind makes a massive shift.  But if there's enough wind to warrant flying the leeward hull when the wind is to leeward, you should be on the sheet anyway, even if you always keep the windward hull is to windward.


<<I don't particularly like the wrinkles on the ww side.>>

  That might be a necessary evil when wishbones are in position for a perfect shape on the leeward side.  Fortunately it's the leeward side that really matters.  Given that the joint on the windward side is already in a relatively dead zone, a few wrinkles at that point on the windwoard side should be a non-issue.


<<If the timber wishbones were skinned with some carbon tow>>

  Nice thought.  The quick build time of plywood and spruce wishbones, combined with the strength of carbon.

        - Mike

 

On 5/28/2010 11:56 PM, robert wrote:

 

I had a good look at the sheeting arrangements. They sheet way back to the stern. This would not really go with the Harryproa configuration of sheeting back to the ww hull. Posssibly sheet back to a pulley midway betweent the two bows. I suspect the hinge would have to be made extra strong to handle the different sheeting arrangements. If the timber wishbones were skinned with some carbon tow, they should handle the extra loads. It would probably be worth it aiming for an optimum leeward shape.
I don't particularly like the wrinkles on the ww side. Possibly cutting the sails on the bias could smooth things.

I am concerned about the sheeting angles. Hopefully Gardner can sort it out before I commit.
regards,
Robert


__._,_.___
Recent Activity:
Visit Your Group
.

__,_._,___