Subject: Re: [harryproa] Weights for larger proas?
From: Rob Denney
Date: 2/6/2011, 2:16 AM
To: harryproa@yahoogroups.com.au
Reply-to:
harryproa@yahoogroups.com.au

 

Could definitely build it lighter using flat panels.  Not sure how much because i do npt know the actual hull weights of RB.  Sol is 450 gsm glass either side of 10mm foam, 2.6 kgs per sq m, with just over half as much again glass added for local strength in the lee hull.  RB would be 15mm foam with 600 either side, 3.6 kgs per sq m, and half as much again in the lee hull.  The flat panel savings are the vacuuming, the lack of glassed joins and the lack of fairing.    The weight of the ww hul depends on panel size.  Big panels need extra thickness foam or frames/stringers/etc. 

If this is not what you want, let me know.

rob

On Sun, Feb 6, 2011 at 7:59 AM, Gardner Pomper <gardner@networknow.org> wrote:
 

Rob,


After hearing about 48' containers, I experimented with lengthening the lw and ww hulls on a design I was working on that was just a bit too cramped in the harryproa 12m size. The thing that worries me is that I might have crossed a point where the weight/sq ft starts going up dramatically. The reason I ask is that harryproa weighs 800kg and rare bird weighs 3054kgs.

I checked your numbers for Solitarry (1.2lbs/sq ft for lw hull, 0.75 lbs/sq ft for ww hull) and found that it matched what I have been calculating also. My ww hull is 1250 sq ft (125 sqm) and the lw hull is 400 sq ft (40 sqm), so I am getting a combined hull weight of about 1500 lbs (700kg), which is probably a bit higher than harry. I am guessing at a total weight of 2500 lbs (1130kg). I would be fine with that, but Rare Birds' 3000kg weight scares me.

Do you think that you could build a flat panel version of rare bird now, with all that you have learned, that would weigh alot less than the strip planked cedar? Or should I be scaling up all the laminate weights because my righting moment is about 10 tonne-meters, as opposed to harry's 6 tonne-meters? I can see having to beef up the lw hull and the beams, but the ww hull isn't taking more load.

You know everything revolves around the weight, so if I screw that up then everything is screwed up. If i just assume that I have to double the weight of everything, then my sail plan doesn't work.

Any advice? Is there some other info you need to give me an idea?

- Gardner
Pasadena, MD


__._,_.___
Recent Activity:
Visit Your Group
.

__,_._,___