Subject: Re: [harryproa] New description for proas
From: Rob Denney
Date: 3/19/2011, 9:22 PM
To: harryproa@yahoogroups.com.au
Reply-to:
harryproa@yahoogroups.com.au

 

Good luck!  Trying to describe something as different as a harryproa to non proa people will always result in misunderstandings.   Describing a 40'ter as a 20'ter is probably more honest, but will upset a lot more people than the other way round.  Particularly racing types, the registration bureaucrats and the marina operators.

rob

On Wed, Mar 16, 2011 at 7:42 AM, Gardner Pomper <gardner@networknow.org> wrote:
 

From all the postings on the net, trying to explain proas to people, and from trying to do it myself, I think that I have finally begun to understand the lack of understanding. One of the main descriptions I have seen is that a proa is like a trimaran, missing one ama. I think this gives a misleading sense of the size, since when we talk about a 38' Harry, it is not at all equivalent to a 38' trimaran. I think it would probably be better to describe an Atlantic proa as a trimaran that has both of its amas on the same side, just merged into a single double-length ama. Then say that a Harry is an atlantic proa, except that we put the mast in the ama.


Along with this, I think it would be more clear if we described a Harry as a 9m boat with a 12m ama, instead of a 12m boat. I was just looking at my old 25' trimaran, and realizing that it is pretty close to a harrigami, if you just put both the amas on the same side. What with the unstayed rig, and always keeping the mast to lw, the Harrigami is maybe 10% lighter than my trimaran, but it is a pretty close comparison. If I were to describe a harrigami as a 35' boat, people would get totally the wrong mental picture, until they really understood (which isn't likely to happen).

Anyway, next time I try to describe my raider design, I am going to tell people that it is like a 26' trimaran, except that I combined both amas into one long one and moved the mast over to the ama and see how they react <grin>.

Just a thought,

- Gardner


__._,_.___
Recent Activity:
Visit Your Group
.

__,_._,___