Subject: Re: [harryproa] Re: 12' wide folding maxi-trailerable
From: "Rob Denney harryproa@gmail.com [harryproa]" <harryproa@yahoogroups.com.au>
Date: 9/23/2019, 8:12 PM
To: harryproa@yahoogroups.com.au
Reply-to:
harryproa@yahoogroups.com.au

 

Great bunch of threads.  I have got a bit behind (working on the Marshall's project and the 24m cargo ferry prototype), so apologies for the messy answers in the following replies.  If I have missed anything, please let me know.


Honestly, that's very sexy. Closed, light, and very simple.

Does this even need internal lines? Can they not all just be external? Address's the maintenance. Show off how stupid simple it is?

No problem with external.  They could also be removable, with a pin through the straps to keep them in place.  


(Side note, no reason I could not build for my E25, to test?)

Sure.


Perhaps UHMWPE as bearing surfaces?

Yes


Can 2 almost 12' beams that go almost to the outside of each hull get us to ~22’? If I did the maths right.

Can those beams get good strong bury to each hull and still let the other beam slide in that deep?

Not really.  The lower oney cannot (easily) go through the hull.  The holeto do so need to be sealed and it is a highly stressed area so reinforcement needs to be considered.  If the top beam was flush with the deck, that side would not be a problem.  


Perhaps need a 3rd beam to get the width to 25'+?

Can add as many as you like.  ;-)


Lowest beam to windward, and highest to lee?

Yes.  Unless you want the tender to stay attached.


Perhaps if we get the beam lengths dialed in, we can get a final length, then we can start seeing how the parts rack and stack?

It won't make any difference.  The straps need to be a tight fit when sailing and strong enough to resist all the loads.    Another option is to use the rigid straps only for opening/closing and use ratchet straps to lock them together when sailing.


| Complicated indeed, but the pros and cons of each are pretty clear.
| As are the compromises that need to be made.

Are there any we have not addressed? Or not addressed enough?

The telescoping seems able to get good structural bury and great extension very simply and lightly.

Mike, et. al. Any thoughts?

| > So lets just assume tillers?
| >
| Definitely. And with telescoping extensions.

Mike said this was preferred anyway, IIRC.

| > Can the toy box and winches be removable and also still hold the anchor well when anchored?
| >
| Yes.
|
| >
| > Any ideas?
| >
| Several, but they are all compromises. Need to decide what is important...
| If you are opening and closing the boat either side of a 2 hour sail after work, the requirements are different to taking it apart to take it home once a season.

Tell me more.

A third target is the cruiser who wants a mono slip, perhaps? Call that guy Arto?

So, if Mike is a once a season guy, Arto is a cruiser, and I am the 2 hour guy. How does optimizing for me tick the other two off?

Mostly it is about looks, ease of build and practicalities.  Mike would be better with one piece demountable beams.  Arto will need to consider what goes between the hulls and you need to organise your trailer..


| > How about when collapsed can the bench seat slide over the lee hull? That eliminates the storage under them I guess.
| >
| Yes and yes
|
| >
| > Or just make the benches removable as boxes, to keep the storage? Assuming they are not a structural part of the lee cabin wall.
| >
| They aren't, but they have to be put somewhere, as does the tender and anything else removed.

Trailering, perhaps the bench boxes and toy box may stack under, fore, and aft of the boat. Put the T40?? On its side impaled on its lifts by the gin poles or mast stubs?

Lots of options.  Would need o draw it out and see what fits where.  


How high is the lee hull?

1m/40"

Add the T40 width and 33" for the trailer. Are we under 14'?

Probably, but it is not easy moving things on their sides.  


If you are in a slip and you got a T40?? where do you put it? Can you just tie it behind your boat? Will it fit under? Swamp it, and slide it under in the slip? Same with the boxes?

Swamping is not viable.  Under would work if it was antifouled.   Tieing it behind might upset people.  Using the boom as a crane and leaving it on deck is probably best.


Will the boxes float under the boat? Perhaps not the toybox.

Floating gets messy pretty quickly.  Stacking on deck, or perhaps on the marina arm works better.  


I hope I didn't embarrass myself too much.

No more than usual.  ;-)

__._,_.___

Posted by: Rob Denney <harryproa@gmail.com>
Reply via web post Reply to sender Reply to group Start a new topic Messages in this topic (28)

.

__,_._,___